New Iran sanctions continue discussion on 'proportionality'

The Trump administration added another high-ranking Iranian official this week to its list of sanctions against Iran, inviting continued discussion about the morality of lethal and non-lethal means of resolving conflicts.

Highlights

By (CNA/EWTN)
Catholic Online (https://www.catholic.org)
8/2/2019 (5 years ago)

Published in U.S.

Washington D.C., (CNA) - The Trump administration announced on Wednesday that it would take action against Iran's foreign minister Mohammad Javad Zarif as the "face" of the regime in Iran. The move is a continuation of President Trump's Executive Order 13876 in June, which issued sanctions against Iran's Supreme Leader Ali Hosseini Khamenei and his office, and placed Supreme Leader Khameni on the Office of Foriegn Assets Control (OFAC) List of Specially Designated Nationals and Blocked Persons.

As part of that order, Zarif on Wednesday was added to the OFAC list, which freezes the U.S. assets of the named individuals and prevents people in the U.S. from dealing with them.

A senior administration official told reporters on Wednesday that Zarif "is the international face of this regime," spreading "propaganda" on behalf of its "nuclear program," "terrorist network," execution of homosexuals and detention of Washington Post journalist Jason Rezaian.

In June, Zarif defended the regime's executions of homosexuals in a joint press conference with the German foreign minister, telling a reporter from the German tabloid Bild the law was based on "moral principles."

"While the United States has historically placed a high priority on preserving space for diplomacy, there are limits to our patience when a regime so routinely flouts these protocols," a senior administration official told reporters on Wednesday.

In June, President Trump said he called off a planned missile strike against Iran, in retaliation for Iran shooting down a U.S. drone, because the use of force would not be "proportionate" to the shooting of the drone. Moral theologians explained to CNA the Church's teaching on the proportionate use of force in a just war; "the use of arms must not produce evils or disorders graver than the evil to be eliminated," Dr. Kevin Miller, a moral theologian at Franciscan University of Steubenville, said to CNA.

And when the use of military force is not "proportionate" to an act of aggression, or is not the "last resort" against an unjust aggressor, other "non-lethal" means of pursuing peace must be employed, Monsignor Stuart Swetland, president of Donnelly College, explained to CNA earlier in July.

Regarding the morality of sanctions in general, they must be judged in the context of the "promotion of peace," and must always be used with the goal of bringing the parties to the negotiating table, he said.

Sanctions can take many forms, from targeted sanctions against individual human rights abusers to sanctions against whole sectors of a country's economy such as import or export bans; "they can't be used indiscriminately," Swetland said, and must be "continuously reevaluated" as they are applied.

Enjoy Daily Readings? Pay it Forward

The broader the sanctions are, he continued, the more scrutiny they merit; "when ordinary people can't get food and medicine, it's gone too far," he said.

The actions against Zarif are part of the Trump administration's "maximum pressure campaign" against Iran, a senior administration official told reporters on Wednesday.

Since announcing that the U.S. would be withdrawing from the 2015 nuclear deal between Iran and other world powers" a deal that lifted international sanctions on Iran in exchange for the regime curbing its nuclear program" the U.S. has reimposed sanctions and placed additional sanctions on Iran, including on goods such as aluminum and oil exports.

Citizens in Iran have reported feeling the brunt of economic sanctions, having difficulty accessing needed medical treatments and paying higher costs for food, as CNA reported previously; the Associated Press reported on Tuesday that the cost of imported medicines in Iran have sharply increased.