Skip to content
Catholic Online Logo

By Marshall Connolly, Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

9/16/2013 (7 months ago)

Catholic Online (www.catholic.org)

Scientists and journalists are making mistakes in the climate change debate, and it's costing us.

Recently, Catholic Online published a story on the expansion of Arctic sea ice, suggesting the expansion of the ice represents a setback for the strident global-warming alarmist community. However, upon cool review of the evidence, the conclusion may be premature.

Polar bears are among the most photogenic of the endangered species and icons of Arctic climate change.

Polar bears are among the most photogenic of the endangered species and icons of Arctic climate change.

Article Highlights

By Marshall Connolly, Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

Catholic Online (www.catholic.org)

9/16/2013 (7 months ago)

Published in Technology

Keywords: global warming, climate change, ice caps, temprature, pollution, scientists, consensus, flooding, mistakes, debate, journalists


LOS ANGELES, CA (Catholic Online) - I commonly write on climate change as a favorite topic and have interviewed several climatologists about the issue. My coworkers engage me in friendly discussions and the recent report in the Daily Mail that proved the surface area of Arctic sea ice was expanding, provided the fodder for some ribbing in my direction.

However, I am not an "alarmist" as some may accuse, but rather I feel we need to assess the scientific evidence and make measured and calculated decisions that are grounded in both science and morality.

There are four basic problems with the current discussion.

1.    We're using "global warming" interchangeably with "climate change."

The climate changes naturally over long periods of time. Even within short periods, there can be some level of change. Volcanic activity, variations in solar output, ratios of greenhouse gasses in the atmosphere all bring about fluctuations in the climate, no humans required.

It is important to make the distinction. Climate change is the overall pattern of changes in regional climate as a result of changes in the overall temperature of the planet, or more accurately, with the level of energy circulating between the planet's crust and the upper atmosphere. Some desert areas may become green, ice caps may melt, or grow, and predominant weather patterns may shift.

Greening desert in China. As the climate shifts, some places turn to desert, others green.

Greening desert in China. As the climate shifts, some places turn to desert, others green.


At the present time, climate change appears to be spurred by global warming, which is the average rise of air temperature around the planet over a period of time. That this is happening is beyond question. What is subject to debate are the causes of that warming, or specifically, to what degree are humans responsible for it.

2.    Reality is incredibly complex, so models can only provide mediocre predictions, not precision. Trends should be the basis for policy. Both sides are putting too much stock in modeled predictions.

It should come as little surprise to anyone with an interest in the weather that climatologists can't accurately predict what will happen from one year to the next. This year has shown us a couple of major climate surprises already. The first was the announcement that the Arctic ice cap grew in area as opposed to shrinking altogether as previously feared. In 2007, alarmist headlines ominously warned that the Arctic ice cap would disappear in the summer. Encouraged by the news, several boating enthusiasts attempted to traverse the fabled "Northwest Passage." Today, their boats are stuck in ice and a Canadian icebreaker is moving to rescue them.

In other news, the hurricane season, predicted to be especially active and robust, has been the second most quiet in history, at least to date. Both of these climate surprises illustrate how inaccurate some predictions are.

We shouldn't be surprised. How often are local weather predictions changed up until the hour at which they occur? If the weather anchor on the news can't nail the local weather, how can we expect scientists to accurately guess the weather many years from now? We can't.

What we are learning, and this is painfully evident as dire predictions are missed, that the planet is a very sophisticated system and the variables are plentiful. For example, why do our climate models show warming, with that trend reaching a plateau over the past decade?

Nature abhors straight lines. We can draw trends, but we cannot guarantee what will happen tomorrow, furthermore decades from now. This does not invalidate the trends, but instead suggests we need to take precise predictions about tomorrow with a grain of salt. Instead, the media in particular, myself included, goes for the big headline. After all, dire headlines capture readers. Nobody wants to read that it will just be mildly unpleasant when we can regale them with tales of superstorms and a mad-Max-style dystopian future where we live on a desert planet.

Although temperatures have plateaued,  in the past decade, they have still risen faster than at any

Although temperatures have plateaued, in the past decade, they have still risen faster than at any time before in recorded history. This is the heart of the problem.


Will tomorrow's climate be warmer? Overall, certainly. Guessing how much and when is the hard part. However, we do know the warming is coming and it's coming fast. More on that in a moment.

3.    People on both sides of the issue are not thinking three-dimensionally.

This issue coincides with the former in that natural systems are multi-dimensional. We are accustomed to working with pairs of variables, such as supply vs. demand and the like, but nature is hardly obliging. The satellite photos don't lie. The Arctic ice cap is larger than it was last year, and much more extensive than predicted.

The problem here is that images can be spun, and journalists lie. Perhaps not deliberately, perhaps they are misinformed or they simply don't understand, but just because something is published on the Daily Mail or the WSJ, doesn't mean it should be automatically awarded gospel status. Yes, that even goes for the content I write, I'm fairly well-versed, but my words alone shouldn't make for gospel.

So what about that ice cap? As quickly as the media flew headlines proclaiming "global cooling" scientists quickly followed to explain that overall volume is much less than in previous years. In fact, the same phenomenon may be what we're observing in the Antarctic. The Antarctic ice sheets are expanding in terms of surface area, but they are also thinning. As meltwater makes its way to the sea and refreezes, it has the effect of spreading the surface area of the ice while the icesheet grows thinner. It's much like an ice cream cone melting on pavement. As the frozen treat melts, the mess spreads out over a wider area.

The Daily Mail

The Daily Mail's image showing the change in the extent of Arctic ice.


This is a good illustration of the problem. Journalists are viewing the ice caps two-dimensionally, in terms of length and width, and ignoring depth.

Overall, the trend in ice is downwards. As with any statistics in a natural environment, there will be variation. There will be statistical outliers. However, we should also be able to extrapolate a trend over time. This is where the focus must be.

If we should find that the current temperature trend reverses, then we will need to have a different discussion. However, for the time being a slowing of the pace of warming isn't the same as stopping or reversal. It's still getting warmer, year over year on average, and we need to explain it and do something about it.

4.    Why do we need to act? Because climate change is real and it's happening faster than at any time in history.

Not even in prehistoric times have we witnessed such a rapid change in climate for either warmer or colder.  This is a problem because plants and animals need to adapt to changes otherwise they will become extinct. Already, thousands and likely millions of species are susceptible to extinction as a result of climate change.

It is a fact that nature selects some species for extinction. Mother Nature is cruelly indifferent to the vagaries of climate, but there is a mechanism that can save these species, known as natural selection. However, for natural selection to result in favorable adaptations it requires dozens, perhaps hundreds of successive generations. It works well, but it's a slow process.

Meanwhile, we're warming the planet at an astounding rate, changing ecosystems faster than some organisms can adapt. Polar bears are a favorite example. As the arctic ice melts, polar bears lose more of their crucial habitat.

Other organisms seem to be adapting better than others. Atlantic lobster stocks are moving north. Insects are invading new territory. Plants are growing in places where before there was only ice or sand.

The Earth's atmosphere is a very thin layer compared to the rest of the planet. We depend on clean air for survival. We need breathable air, we need rain and snow, and measures of sunlight to survive. Despite the limited quantity of clean, breathable air, we seem to have little problem with industrializing and polluting it as we go. Likewise, we pollute our water and food supplies, slash-and-burn our forests, clear the oceans, and devour everything we touch.

At the top of this pyramid of excess, we sit as Americans consuming a significant, double-digit portion of the world's resources in food and energy, while making just a fraction of its population. To do this, then leave in our wake a trail of pollution for our children to clean up is immoral.

It is difficult to argue we should make dramatic changes to our quality of life and consumption habits. But as a nation we have followed policies, combined with our natural wealth in land, that have made us wealthy. We're accustomed to the good life and can't imagine different.

I don't know what we need to do to avert or mitigate a future crisis, which I still worry is looming. However, until we work on the problems listed above, we will continue to debate about the reality and significance of global climate change and warming until time to avert any crisis is already long past.


Click to learn about our Saint Michael the Archangel conference this Nov 1-3!

---


Pope Francis calls for your 'Prayer and Action'


© 2014 - Distributed by THE NEWS CONSORTIUM

Pope Francis Prayer Intentions for March 2014
Respect for Women:
That all cultures may respect the rights and dignity of women.
Vocations: That many young people may accept the Lord’s invitation to consecrate their lives to proclaiming the Gospel.



Comments


More Technology

A NEW EARTH? Astronomers discover remarkably similar planet to our own Watch

Image of The Goldilocks zone, or habitable zone, is the belt around a star where temperatures are ideal for liquid water to pool on a planet's surface.

By Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

Astronomers have announced that they have found a planet that is remarkably similar to Earth. Called Kepler-186f, the planet 1.1 times the size of Earth orbiting a star - "only" 490 light years away. Kepler-186f is the first planet discovered with the right ... continue reading


EYES TO THE HEAVENS: Astronomers say there may be a 'new Saturn moon' Watch

Image of The disturbance in the edge of the ring is 20 percent brighter than its surroundings and about 750 miles long and six miles wide.

By Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

All eyes are on the heavens as astronomers theorize that another moon for the ringed planet of Saturn may be on its way. If the heavenly body in the rings of Saturn is confirmed, it would make for the planet's 63rd moon. LOS ANGELES, CA (Catholic Online) - ... continue reading


IS THE SECOND COMING NIGH? Four blood moons this year all occur on Jewish holidays Watch

Image of

By Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

As climate change wreaks havoc worldwide, and relations between the U.S. and Russia reach a low point over Ukraine, some Christians say that the phenomenon of the "Blood moon" may mean that Christ's return is rapidly approaching. LOS ANGELES, CA (Catholic ... continue reading


Will Alibaba devour Facebook? China's massive Alibaba is coming to conquer the United States Watch

Image of Yahoo's dominance has since dwindled as Alibaba has since grown into a global powerhouse.

By Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

Ali Baba for those in the west usually means the storybook leader of a gang of fearless, 40 thieves. But this will soon change. A massive e-commerce site from China, Alibaba, with revenue larger than Amazon and eBay combined has decided to go public in the ... continue reading


Drone images reveal more about mysterious buried village in New Mexico Watch

Image of Drone images have captured fascinating new details about a buried Native American village in New Mexico.

By Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

Drone images have captured fascinating new details about a buried Native American village in New Mexico. Thermal images captured by the small drone allowed archaeologists to peer under the surface of the desert floor, revealing never-before-seen structures. LOS ... continue reading


New 'Star Wars' gun fires shells seven times the speed of sound through concrete -- 100 miles away Watch

Image of The rail gun will be mounted on high-speed vessel the USNS Millinocket for sea trials in 2016.

By Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

A futuristic lethal new weapon capable of firing a shell at seven times the speed of sound has since been successfully tested on land. Conjuring up images of iconic sci-fi villains as Darth Vader, researchers have called the new rail gun as being of 'Star Wars' ... continue reading


KETTLE CALLING THE POT BLACK? Internet search engines exhibiting double standards Watch

Image of An old cliche -- that bears repeating --

By Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

Certain cliché sayings come to mind: The kettle calling the pot black, having one's cake and eating it too . Google, along with Facebook and Yahoo have come down hard on the Obama administration for information gathering - but NOW don't want their ... continue reading


Scientists discover massive asteroid hit Earth so hard that oceans evaporated Watch

Image of Earth was struck several times by massive asteroids billions of years ago.

By Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

Scientists from Stanford University say they have found evidence of another cataclysmic cosmic collision between Earth and another asteroid billions of years ago. This asteroid, they say, was so large it punched a hole in the Earth's crust and caused earthquakes around ... continue reading


Why is NASA rejecting definitive proof of life on Mars? Watch

Image of Curiosity recently captures this image that shows light on the ground on Mars. NASA thinks it's just a glint off rock or some other similar anomaly.

By Marshall Connolly, Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

The Curiosity rover has photographed what appears to be light emanating from the ground on Mars. UFO and alien life enthusiasts as well as conspiracy theorists have all claimed the light is evidence of life on the Red Planet. NASA however, is not so sure. LOS ANGELES, ... continue reading


HANG ON TOTO! Astronomers calculate the speed of the Universe's expansion Watch

Image of Hang on! The universe is expanding at 1 percent per 44 million years, which is fast if you consider the size of the universe is at least 46 billion years in radius!

By Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

Hold on to your hat, Toto, we're about to leave Kansas. Astronomers say they have calculated the expansion rate of the universe and their discovery is very surprising. LOS ANGELES, CA (Catholic Online) - Astronomers have long been interested in measuring the expansion ... continue reading


All Technology News

Newsletters

Newsletter Sign Up icon

Stay up to date with the latest news, information, and special offers

Daily Readings

Reading 1, Genesis 1:1--2:2
1 In the beginning God created heaven and ... Read More

Psalm, Psalms 16:5, 8, 9-10, 11
5 My birthright, my cup is Yahweh; you, you alone, ... Read More

Gospel, Matthew 28:1-10
1 After the Sabbath, and towards dawn on the first ... Read More

Reading 2, Genesis 22:1-18
1 It happened some time later that God put Abraham to ... Read More

Saint of the Day

Saint of the Day for April 19th, 2014 Image

St. Alphege
April 19: Archbishop and "the First Martyr of Canterbury." He was born in ... Read More

Inform, Inspire & Ignite Logo

Find Catholic Online on Facebook and get updates right in your live feed.

Become a fan of Catholic Online on Facebook


Follow Catholic Online on Twitter and get News and Product updates.

Follow us on Twitter