Skip to content
Catholic Online Logo

By Andrew M. Greenwell, Esq.

8/26/2013 (7 months ago)

Catholic Online (www.catholic.org)

The Catechism of the Catholic Church provides that '[e]veryone, man and woman, should acknowledge and accept his sexual identity.' (CCC § 2333) That identity is both-soul-and-body and it is only one of two: male or female.

The LGBT crowd has been busy touting as poster children to their cause the strange and curious (and one might say perverse) engagement of the transgender Welsh couple Jamie Eagle and Louis Davies.  Behind all of this propaganda is an erroneous view of the human person, even what might be called an "anti-theology of the body."

Article Highlights

By Andrew M. Greenwell, Esq.

Catholic Online (www.catholic.org)

8/26/2013 (7 months ago)

Published in Marriage & Family

Keywords: gender identity, Pope Benedict XVI, transgender, transgender couple, theology of the body, anti-theology of the bodyAndrew M. Greenwell


CORPUS CHRISTI, TX (Catholic Online) - Blessed John Paul II's teaching on the theological importance of the human body is popularly referred to as the Theology of the Body.  It is a theology based upon anthropology.  That is to say, it is a theology based upon a particular view of man. 
The Theology of the Body insists on seeing man as he is: an ensouled body or an embodied soul, a unity of body-and-soul. 

In a nutshell, like all sound-thinking Catholics, in his reflections John Paul II rejected the anthropological model proposed by the philosopher Rene Descartes which is the preferred model of moderns.  In the modern or Cartesian view, man is, in the words of the philosopher Gilbert Ryle, a "ghost in a machine," with the body being a machine and the person in command being the ghost. 

For the modern mind influenced by Descartes' dualism, man is sort of like an Arquilian in the movie Men in Black.  Those who have seen the movie might remember how Gentle Rosenburg is not Gentle Rosenburg at all, but an Arquillian who is in command of a human-like exosuit that looks like Gentle Rosenburg. 

For modern dualists, the body, including its sex and sexual faculties, is just an exosuit.  The real thing, though no one can see it, is the Arquillian within.

For Catholics, on the other hand, the reality is the body-and-soul composite: the person is body-and-soul.  The body is a critical element to understanding the reality of man.  Man must not be seen as a ghost in a machine.  Seeing man that way perverts reality.

To have an adequate grasp of reality, one must see the body not as a "vessel or vehicle of the soul," but rather, as the theologian David Bentley Hart has put it, one must see the body as the soul's "material manifestation, expression, and occasion."

While in his Theology of the Body John Paul II articulates his thought in a novel way, his thought falls within the framework of Thomistico-Aristotelian view that the soul is the form of the body (anima forma corporis). 

The body is as influenced by the soul as the soul is influenced by the body, so that--while distinct--they cannot be separated as if they were different self-subsisting realities.  Our bodies, in particular their sex, affects us as persons.  A soul is male or female depending upon whether the body is male or female. 

It is therefore incongruous to believe that one can have a male soul in a female body.  That's why the Catechism of the Catholic Church provides that "[e]veryone, man and woman, should acknowledge and accept his sexual identity." (CCC § 2333)  That identity is both-soul-and-body and it is only one of two: male or female.

Modern man, however, has rejected this view on the basis of a false freedom.  Falsely thinking it a good, modern man wants autonomy or freedom from his nature, even his sex.  The modern dualistic view of man translates to the fact that the body means nothing to the soul.  The soul, in fact, is viewed as the overlord, even the tyrant, of the body, a body without meaning and without rights vis-ą-vis the soul.  The soul must be free of the body, as it is incomprehensible that the soul should be answerable to a slave, to mere biology. 

This, of course, is completely antithetical to the classical and Judaeo-Christian view, which is based upon reality--what is.  Moreover, the Christian view in particular puts great value on the human body, male or female, as it is something important enough for God to have become joined with, and important enough for him to have redeemed, and good enough to be the object of the grace of Resurrection and merit eternal life. 

The effect on morality of the modern debasement of the body is significant because if the body means nothing, then it can be used as a tool: it has nothing to say in the moral forum.  In determining what is morally good, the body is gagged.  Only the soul is allowed to speak.  And when one party has no voice, that party is invariably the loser.  In the language of Jean-Francois Lyotard, the body is involved in a differend, because it has no way to express its importance.

One who has fallen for the view that the real person is separate from the body will deprecate his body, like most masters do their slaves.  The disembodied person believes he or she can exercise despotic control over his body as if the body were slave to the soul.  Such a person has adopted what David Bentley Hart has called an "Anti-Theology of the Body."  Since it is based upon a false view of reality, it is really more of an ideology than a theology.

As David Bentley Hart astutely observes, what is involved between the traditional view and the modern view of man is not merely a difference "between two radically antagonistic visions of what it is to be a human being."  Ultimately, what lies behind this dualism is "two radically antagonistic visions of what it is to be a god."

Starkly put: is the Creator God?  Or is man god?

In his Christmas greetings to the curia in 2008, Pope Benedict XVI spoke about this view of the body, specifically in the context of gender.

"When the Church speaks of the nature of the human being as man and woman and asks that this order of creation be respected," Pope Benedict XVI said, "it is not the result of an outdated metaphysic.  It is a question here of faith in the Creator and of listening to the language of creation, the devaluation of which leads to the self-destruction of man and therefore to the destruction of the same work of God."

Pope Benedict XVI continued.  "That which is often expressed and understood by the term 'gender', results finally in the self-emancipation of man from creation and from the Creator.  Man wishes to act alone and to dispose ever and exclusively of that alone which concerns him.  But in this way he is living contrary to the truth, he is living contrary to the Spirit Creator."

The LGBT crowd would not exist without this Anti-Theology of the Body, an anti-theology which is "contrary to the truth," "contrary to the Spirit Creator."  For the LGBT crowd, the body--especially its sex and its sexual faculties--is hardly a sacred repository of God's truth about human nature, about human sexuality, about human personhood, about one's self.

In his Politics, Aristotle observed that a small philosophical misstep in the beginning of a journey results in one missing his destination by miles, which in philosophy is a grasp upon reality, what is.  If the misstep is a large one--in this case, a wrong Cartesian, dualistic view of man--there will be a total failure to reach one's destination.  One ends up in the La-La land of unreality, where boys are girls and girls are boys.

Case in point.  The LGBT crowd has been busy touting as poster children to their cause the strange and curious (and one might say perverse) engagement of the transgender Welsh couple Jamie Eagle and Louis Davies

This is the bizarre sort of brave new world stuff an Anti-Theology of the Body ushers in.  "By going public," this chimerical couple says, "we are changing history."  Well, maybe.  But whatever they're doing, they certainly are not making their lives any more real; rather, they are making it more fantastical. 

Despite being born a boy, Jamie has convinced himself that his "ghost" is a female.  He is attracted to males, but not as a male, but rather as a female. 

Despite being born a girl (who was named Samantha), Louis says she always felt like a boy.  Her "ghost" was a boy, she believes, thought her machinery was clearly that of a girl.  Her "defining moment," she says, occurred at puberty, when she realized that she would eventually grow breasts, something she feared as if it were a nightmare.  Hatred of her female body showed itself in self-abusive behavior, including drugs.

Jamie and Louis are sick psychologically.  Add to that sickness a false philosophy based upon a false anthropology, and it is a recipe for fantasy taking over reality, and then forcing those with a grasp on reality to accept the fantasy.

Tragically, this couple of human beings seem, quite probably initially through no fault of their own, to have been captured by what the Pontifical Council for the Family in its guidelines The Truth and Meaning of Human Sexuality has called "deviant tendencies and attitudes." 

These, it says, "require great prudence and caution so as to recognize and evaluate situations properly."  Often, "recourse to specialists with solid scientific and moral formation," including "doctors, educations experts, and psychologists with an upright Christianity sensitivity," is required to "identify the causes over and above the symptoms, and help the subject to overcome difficulties in a serious and clear way." (No. 72)

But instead of providing them real help to solve the apparent disconnect between their psyches and their bodies and reconcile themselves with the reality of their bodies, psychologists and physicians whose "science" and "technology" is based upon an Anti-Theology of the Body and the LGBT propaganda will alter reality--the body--to conform to the unreal fantasy under which they labor.

In fact, these exert political pressure or pass laws to assure that competing viewpoints are squelched as unscientific or unenlightened.  Then, for good measure, they call opponents perverse and insensitive for thinking this lapse into fantasy perverse.  The world becomes topsy turvy.

Expressed in the language of Men in Black, the advocates of LGBT rights inform Jamie and Louis that their bodies are exosuits.  Jamie's male exosuit can be changed with surgery and hormones to a female exosuit so as to conform to the supposed female Arquillian within.  Louis's female exosuit can be changed with surgery and hormones to a male exosuit so as to conform to the supposed male Arquillian within.

This, of course, is an abuse, as it involves bodily mutilation and an improper deprecation of the gift of the body.  As Pope Pius XI observed in his encyclical Casti Conubii: "Christian doctrine establishes, and the light of human reason makes it most clear, that private individuals have no other power over the members of their bodies than that which pertains to their natural ends, and they are not free to destroy or mutilate their members, or in any other way render themselves unfit for their natural functions, except when no other provision can be made for the good of the whole body."  (No. 71)

But this is true only if God is the Creator, and if we do not see ourselves autonomous of, and not answerable to, God the Creator.  Modern man does not see himself that way.  So the voice of reason and the teachings of Pius XI are seen as restrictive, instead of freeing.

As the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith has observed such superficial surgery "does not change the personality.  If the person was male, he remains male.  If she was female, she remains female."  This is common sense.

But LGBT ideology is not about common sense.  Encouraged by the false LGBT ideology, Jamie and Louis see themselves masters over their bodies, and they will make their bodies fit their unreal perception regarding the gender that they are.  They see themselves master over marriage and master over the expression of their sexual selves.

"It's not the wrong body I've got, just the wrong parts.  I literally hate my parts and tried to cut them off as a teenager," Jamie says.  Now, the deft hands of a surgeon will satisfy the abnormal hatred he has of his body by mutilating the body God has given him.  To "hate my parts" means the ghost hates the machine.  What Jamie is really saying is that he hates himself, and surgery will not cure that.

Similarly, Louis has taken artificial hormones which distort her feminine body, and have given it a pronounced jawline, an Adam's apple, facial hair, and a deeper voice.  Louis says she hated the fact that she would have breasts, that is, the "ghost" hated the breasts of the machine.  But to hate one's breasts really means that she hates herself, and removing the breasts and taking hormones will not cure that.
 
If one holds on to a Theology of a Body, one supposes that it may be true that "there's a lot of confusion about us and what we're about," as Jamie says, because the body testifies against the lie that a female soul can reside in a male body or a male soul in a female body.

But if one holds on to an Anti-Theology of the Body, it all becomes clear, so he or she may think:  "I'm a girl," says the boy, "and Louis," the girl "is a boy," because one feels like it, the testimony of the body be damned.

No.  Sorry.  Reality will not have it that way.  For all the fantasy, and for all the surgery and hormones, Jamie is male, and Louis is female, and we ought not to let misfits living in a dream world tell us what reality is.

Blessed Cardinal Newman had the motto which is put on his epitaph: ex umbris et imaginibus in veritatem, "from shades and imaginations to the truth."  That is a motto of sanity, of normality.

Our curious Welsh couple and the LGBT crowd that is pushing them as a poster couple go exactly the opposite way: ex veritate in umbras et imagines, "from truth into shades and imaginations."  That is a motto of insanity, of abnormality.

-----

Andrew M. Greenwell is an attorney licensed to practice law in Texas, practicing in Corpus Christi, Texas.  He is married with three children.  He maintains a blog entirely devoted to the natural law called Lex Christianorum.  You can contact Andrew at agreenwell@harris-greenwell.com.

---


Pope Francis: end world hunger through 'Prayer and Action'


© 2014 - Distributed by THE NEWS CONSORTIUM

Pope Francis Prayer Intentions for April 2014
Ecology and Justice:
That governments may foster the protection of creation and the just distribution of natural resources.
Hope for the Sick: That the Risen Lord may fill with hope the hearts of those who are being tested by pain and sickness.



Comments


More Marriage & Family

Finding Your Best Friend 1,000 Miles Away

Image of Michael and Lauren were married this March.

By Catholic Match

I never really thought it could work, Lauren said, recalling her first encounter with Michael on CatholicMatch. He was so far away a thousand miles honestly didn't think we'd ever be more than friends. Michael and Lauren had free profiles on CatholicMatch, and after an ... continue reading


From Living Large to Putting God in Charge

Image of

By Catholic Match

The year was 1990 and Bob was, in his own words, living large. The then 29-year-old had graduated from Marquette University in Milwaukee several years earlier and spent over a year on the pro golf tour. He went to build a thriving CPA firm and thought himself to be in ... continue reading


Devil at work! Infidelity experts says adultery is good for marriage - if you don't get caught Watch

Image of Since launching in Canada on Valentine's Day in 2002, the adultery Web site has attracted more than 24 million members in 37 countries. South Korea joined last week.

By Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

Ashley Madison is a controversial Web site that enables married men and women to have xtramarital affair. Based in Canada, Noel Biderman is forthright about the right of the married to have affairs -- providing they don't get caught. LOS ANGELES, CA (Catholic ... continue reading


The Path to Happiness for a Young Widow

Image of Bruce and Lauren are now happily married!

By Catholic Match

It's been said the hand of God works by way of coincidences, keeping Him invisible as He illuminates our path. That's how it worked for Bruce and Lauren, and how they get their first sense that something special was afoot. Lauren, 54-years-old, was recently widowed ... continue reading


A Marriage Built on a Firm Rock

Image of Ed and Francis both had great success thanks to CatholicMatch!

By Catholic Match

Frances already had an immensely positive experience with marriage when she came to CatholicMatch. A widow, she had great memories of her years with her late husband and if another marriage was to happen it would have to be on a firm foundation. I had a wonderful ... continue reading


Easy homemade play dough recipes, for the whole family to enjoy.

Image of Home made Play Doh is so much fun.

By Wendy C. R.N., BA

Every child loves to play with play dough and making your own play dough with your child can be fun. Here are three easy recipes for great homemade play dough. Kids are amazed when they learn how easy it is to make play dough wit this activity. The dough can be ... continue reading


Have a Great Family Easter Egg Hunt. Instead of just candy, why not fill your eggs with clues or puzzle pieces, or all sorts of things!

Image of Children love Easter Egg Hunts. Lets make it special this year.

By Wendy C. R.N., BA

Have an Family Easter Egg Hunts this year and fill the eggs with more than just candy. Here are 31 ideas to fill them with, and have fun! LOS ANGELES, CA - Need a fun idea to spruce up your Easter Egg Hunt? Instead of just candy, why not fill your eggs with clues or ... continue reading


Former 'house of horrors' abortion clinic to become emergency food, support center for poor families Watch

Image of The Philadelphia clinic was described as a chaotic

By Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

There is such a thing as a second chance. The notorious Delaware clinic in which abortionist Kermit Gosnell performed late-term abortions and executed children after birth will see a second life as an emergency food and support center for poor families. Lutheran ... continue reading


Hey dads! Pope Francis has an awesome message for you! Watch

Image of Pope Francis follows the example of St. Joseph, and blesses a child. Our clergy are father figures too.

By Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

On the feast day of St. Joseph, Pope Francis spoke directly to dads, encouraging them to follow the example of St. Joseph and remain close to their children. LOS ANGELES, CA (Catholic Online) - Yesterday was the feast day of St. Joseph and Pope Francis used the ... continue reading


Church must reconcile divorce and remarriage, German cardinal says Watch

Image of

By Catholic Online (NEWS CONSORTIUM)

The Church needs to find a middle ground that does not destroy or abandon doctrine in regards to divorce and civil remarriages, Cardinal Walter Kasper says. The church must offer a "renewed" interpretation of Church teaching in order to help those whose ... continue reading


All Marriage & Family News

Newsletters

Newsletter Sign Up icon

Stay up to date with the latest news, information, and special offers

Daily Readings

Reading 1, Acts 3:11-26
11 Everyone came running towards them in great ... Read More

Psalm, Psalms 8:2, 5, 6-7, 8-9
2 even through the mouths of children, or of babes in ... Read More

Gospel, Luke 24:35-48
35 Then they told their story of what had happened on ... Read More

Saint of the Day

Saint of the Day for April 24th, 2014 Image

St. Fidelis of Sigmaringen
April 24: Franciscan Capuchin martyr. He was born Mark Rey is Sigmaringen, ... Read More

Inform, Inspire & Ignite Logo

Find Catholic Online on Facebook and get updates right in your live feed.

Become a fan of Catholic Online on Facebook


Follow Catholic Online on Twitter and get News and Product updates.

Follow us on Twitter